Johnny America

You Nev­er For­get Your First Time

by

Illustration of tennis ball containers

I was in the back­seat with Bil­ly. The first time I’d ever been there with a boy. Fay and Am­ber had talked about what it was like, but the whole thing seemed gross. I couldn’t imag­ine do­ing what they were talk­ing about.

I’d met Bil­ly through ten­nis. We were both on our var­si­ty teams and had en­tered some mixed dou­bles tour­na­ments to­geth­er. He was nice as boys go, and things were be­com­ing serious.

We were mak­ing out when he tried to take it further.

“I’m not ready for that,” I said.

“But don’t you love me?”

“Of course. Just… not that. Not yet.”

“It’s okay. I’ve got a bet­ter idea.”

He reached down on­to the car’s floor and then un­ex­pect­ed­ly held up his Babo­lat Pure Dri­ve ten­nis racket. 

“You’re go­ing to like this,” he said, nod­ding to­ward the rack­et, then be­gin­ning to rub it gen­tly across my skin. 

“What are you do­ing?” I asked, think­ing it ridiculous. 

“Just re­lax. trust me.”

He was right. I felt some­thing I’d nev­er felt be­fore. The grom­mets were cool and firm. The graphite frame moved gen­tly against my collarbone.

“Oh my god,” I whis­pered, not be­liev­ing how good it felt.

The strings brushed against my shoul­der— slow, de­lib­er­ate. The sen­sa­tion was un­like any­thing I’d ever felt. The ten­sion in the strings gave just enough, draw­ing a long, silent line across my skin like a bow over a cello.

My breath caught.

He moved the rack­et down, trac­ing the an­gle of my shoul­der blade. I felt lit from with­in. Glow­ing, be­ing wor­shipped in the lan­guage of pres­sure points and car­bon fiber.

I lost track of time — we could’ve been there an hour — when I no­ticed con­den­sa­tion on the in­side of the car win­dows, saw that the moon had shifted. 

And then I whis­pered, “Let me do it to you.”

He hes­i­tat­ed. “I don’t know.”

“Come on,” I said, gen­tly tak­ing the rack­et. “Just close your eyes.”

I brought the rack­et to his shoul­der. The mo­ment the strings touched his skin, he shuddered.

“Wow, that feels so good,” he said.

We kept trad­ing po­si­tions — me rub­bing him with the Babo­lat Pure Dri­ve, him rub­bing me, us rub­bing our­selves. It was ut­ter­ly deca­dent. And fantastic.

At one point, he said, “Let me do your elbow.”

It was pure bliss. My el­bow had nev­er been touched like that before.

Sud­den­ly, he stopped.

“I’ve got a sur­prise for you,” he said, be­gin­ning to un­buck­le his belt.

“Whoa! I thought we agreed —”

“No, trust me,” he said, reach­ing in­to his shorts.

I couldn’t be­lieve it. Star­ing me in the face was the biggest can of ten­nis balls I had ever seen. I’d heard ru­mors about cans with four balls — but this one had five! And they were Dun­lop Fort Tour­na­ments — the most ex­pen­sive balls on the planet.

“I’m speech­less,” I said. 

“Why have three when you can have five? Am I right?” Then he said with a wink, “Now for the open.”

He pulled back the tab and popped the lid.

Pffft!

I can’t de­scribe the sen­sa­tion I felt in that mo­ment. It eclipsed all pri­or open­ings. Rip­ples of plea­sure shot through me when the vac­u­um seal was re­leased and the smell of the rub­ber in­tox­i­cat­ed me. I was in heaven.

And then, just as quick­ly, it was gone.

“Do you have an­oth­er can?” I asked desperately.

He laughed.

“A D’Antonio al­ways comes pre­pared,” he said, reach­ing in­to his shorts again and pulling out a sec­ond five-ball can.

“Are you ready?” he asked.

“Do it!” I near­ly screamed.

Pffft!

The waves of plea­sure were even more in­tense this time.

“Do you have an­oth­er one?” I pleaded.

He laughed again.

“Ba­by, I can on­ly fit so much in my shorts.”

I was on the verge of some­thing, and I wasn’t about to be denied.

“Make the sound with your mouth.”

“Huh? What?”

“The sound… you know. Of the balls opening.”

“Re­al­ly?”

“Do it!” 

He nod­ded and gave it his best shot.

“Pffft!”

“No, that’s too low in pitch.”

“Pffft?”

“A lit­tle higher!”

“Pffft?”

“Al­most there!”

“Pffft! Pffft! Pffft! Pffft!”

That did it. For a mo­ment, I was out­side my body, float­ing in space. I may have blacked out — the sen­sa­tions were that powerful.

Af­ter­wards, he kept mak­ing the sound over and over, but it be­came annoying.

“Ba­by, just cud­dle me,” I said.

I wish I could tell you that every time was like that. It wasn’t. We’d caught light­ning in a bottle.

And I wish I could tell you we last­ed longer to­geth­er, but he com­mit­ted a se­ri­ous dou­ble fault when he cheat­ed on me with Amber.

“He pulled out his ten­nis rack­et and tried to rub it on me,” she said. “What a weirdo.”

Yeah. Maybe.

But you nev­er for­get your first time.

Filed under Fiction on May 22nd, 2026

Care to Share?

Consider posting a note of comment on this item:

—§—

Previous Post

«

Next Post

Join our Irregular Mailing List

For very occasional ramblings, word about new print ephemera, and of course exciting investment opportunities.